This Halloween special of The Wild Idea is a dramatized conversation in which host Bill Hodge performs Bob Marshall, the forester and Wilderness Society co-founder who died in 1939; it is not an archival interview. Co-host Anders Reynolds questions the character about the real history behind his life: summers on Lower Saranac Lake and the Adirondack 46ers, the winter he spent in Wiseman, Alaska, that became the 1933 book Arctic Village, the October 1934 Knoxville trip that led to the founding of The Wilderness Society in 1935, and the U-1 and U-2 regulations he developed at the U.S. Forest Service to protect roadless areas. The conversation also covers Marshall’s efforts to open public lands to working-class city dwellers and to challenge discrimination in Forest Service recreation policy. The episode closes on a message tied to Marshall’s 1930 essay “The Problem of the Wilderness”: that protected land stays protected only as long as people defend it.

Protected land is only as permanent as the defense of it.

It is Halloween week, Bill Hodge and Anders Reynolds are recording in the same room in Missoula, Montana, and an old Ouija board is on the table. What starts as a joke about the planchette turns into a séance, and Bill, to Anders’s alarm, begins speaking as Bob Marshall: forester, hiker, and the principal founder of The Wilderness Society. Anders drops the planned schedule and interviews him instead.

Marshall’s real life gives the conversation plenty to work with. Anders traces it from childhood summers at his family’s camp on Lower Saranac Lake and the Adirondack high peaks (Marshall, his brother George, and Herb Clark were the first Adirondack Forty-Sixers), through his years at the Forest Service in Missoula and a doctorate in plant physiology at Johns Hopkins, to the winter in Wiseman, Alaska, that produced Arctic Village and the name “Gates of the Arctic.” They talk about his father, the lawyer Louis Marshall, and how those family values show up in Marshall’s insistence that wild country was not only for people who could afford a pack string and a month off. Anders also asks about the 1934 Knoxville drive with Harvey Broome, Benton MacKaye, and others, the Forest Service recreation job that produced the U regulations, and the political heat Marshall took for his socialist views.

The sign-off turns serious. Bill’s Marshall urges listeners to keep up the fight, a message that echoes the ending of Marshall’s 1930 essay: protected land is only as permanent as the defense of it. It is a fitting note for an episode that is mostly a good-natured ghost story, and a reminder that the wilderness protections people rely on today began with a small group of people who organized.

This is a Halloween episode. Bob Marshall died in 1939, and the Marshall you hear in this conversation is a character, performed by co-host Bill Hodge in a scripted bit. His lines are dramatization, not historical quotation. The biographical details in these show notes come from published historical sources.

In this episode:

• A Ouija board and a séance in Missoula Bill and Anders record in person for Halloween, and a joke with a planchette turns into Bill performing Bob Marshall.
• Summers in the Adirondacks Childhood at the family camp on Lower Saranac Lake, and the climb of the Adirondack high peaks with his brother George and Herb Clark.
• A father’s influence Louis Marshall, the constitutional lawyer who helped win “forever wild” protection for the Adirondack and Catskill preserves, and the values Bob took from him.
• Missoula and the fire camps Marshall’s Forest Service years in Missoula, long days on foot in the Swan Range and the South Fork of the Flathead, and what he saw in the fire camps.
• Wiseman and the Brooks Range The Alaska winter behind Arctic Village, the name “Gates of the Arctic,” and the royalties he shared with the people of Wiseman.
• The Knoxville drive and the founding of The Wilderness Society The 1934 trip with Harvey Broome, Benton MacKaye, and others, and the organization that followed in 1935.
• The U regulations The Forest Service rules that protected roadless areas and became a template for the wilderness system.
• Wild country for everyone Marshall’s push to open public lands to working-class city dwellers and to challenge discrimination in Forest Service recreation policy.
• A closing message Why, in this episode’s closing words, public lands are only as permanent as the defense of them.

Links & Resources

Books & Media:

• Arctic Village (1933) — Marshall’s book about the people of Wiseman, Alaska, and a bestseller of its day. 
• The People’s Forests – Marshall’s book makes a passionate case for the public ownership and management of the nation’s forests in the face of generations of devastating practices.
• A Wilderness Original – a 1986 biography written by James M. Glover 

Organizations & Initiatives:

• The Wilderness Society — National conservation organization founded in 1935, with Bob Marshall as a principal founder. 
• Adirondack 46ers — Volunteer club for hikers who have climbed the Adirondack high peaks. 

Places & Landscapes:

• Bob Marshall Wilderness Complex — The Montana wilderness named for Marshall, designated in 1964 and about 1 million acres on its own; the complex with the Scapegoat and Great Bear Wildernesses exceeds 1.5 million acres. 
• Gates of the Arctic National Park and Preserve — Alaska park whose name comes from the term Marshall coined for peaks along the Koyukuk River. 

People Mentioned:

• Bob Marshall (1901–1939) — Forester, author, and principal founder of The Wilderness Society. 
• Harvey Broome — Knoxville lawyer and Wilderness Society co-founder who was part of the 1934 trip. 
• Benton MacKaye — Appalachian Trail proponent and Wilderness Society co-founder.
• Louis Marshall — Bob Marshall’s father, a constitutional and civil rights lawyer.
• Herb Clark — Family friend and fellow Adirondack Forty-Sixer.
• Robert Sterling Yard — Early Wilderness Society leader, mentioned in the episode.
• Gifford Pinchot — First chief of the U.S. Forest Service, mentioned in the episode.

This episode of The Wild Idea is sponsored by The Wilderness Society. 

Learn more about opportunities to sponsor The Wild Idea.

Follow along for updates, upcoming conversations, and live events, and share this episode with someone who cares about wild places, working lands, and the future of our food system. You can also support the show through our Buy Me a Coffee page. 

Subscribe to our show on your favorite podcast player, and be sure to follow us on social media, too: we’re on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn.

We also send out a weekly newsletter with updates on our show: sign up for that list right here.